6 Ultimate Lessons From The Catcher in the Rye

I mean how do you know what you’re going to do till you do it? The answer is, you don’t. I think I am, but how do I know? – Holden Caulfield from The Catcher in the Rye

I absolutely love reading and my favorite book of all time is The Catcher in the Rye by J.D. Salinger. The first time I read it was in my junior year English class during high school. I’ve read it almost every year since then, re-reading it and capturing little tidbits and details here and there that I may have missed the previous times I’ve read the book. And no matter how many times I read it, I still find it highly amusing and a fun read. It’s an American classic, that’s for sure.

Holden Caulfield is the protagonist in the novel and he is one crazy teenage boy trying to find himself in a big man’s world. He certainly has some ideas of whom he ought to be and how things ought to run and is not afraid to voice those opinions of his.

Holden makes several memorable points throughout the story and I’d like to share them with you. Why? Because it’s fun and I can!

6 Ultimate Lessons From The Catcher in the Rye

1. “Grand. There’s a word I really hate. It’s a phony. I could puke every time I hear it.”

Holden is totally and utterly adamant about his hatred for the word “grand.” To us in the 21st century, one may not come across this word in colloquial conversation as often as one would encounter it back during the 1950’s when the story took place.

The underlying concept is what I’m more interested in than the actual choice of word. I equate his emphasis against phonies using the word grand as similar to those who are only acting and speaking a certain way in order to fit in, impress others, boost their ego, seem smart, or compete with others. Whether that’s speaking in a way that’s unlike yourself, acting a certain way that does not depict who you truly are, or dressing a particular way that is not your ultimate style, the bottom line is clear: Be you and not someone else!

2. “All morons hate it when you call them a moron.”

This quote may not have much application, but it certainly is fun!

Isn’t it true, though?

Liars don’t like to be called liars. Cheaters don’t like to call it cheating, more like “it just happened, how was I supposed to help it”? Stealers don’t like to call it stealing, more like “borrowing.” Whatever, dude.

You are who you are and what you do is a reflection of the person and character you are. It is not a separate entity, something that you cannot control. What you do, what you say, what you think … this is what makes up the person that is you, be it a moron, idiot, ninja, vampire, rock star, entrepreneur, or hacker.

3. “The goddam movies. They can ruin you. I’m not kidding.”

Most of you know that I do not watch TV and don’t advocate it either. I really think it’s a serious waste of time. Not just that, but destructive to our lives as well. Emotionally, relationally, and physically. The detriments of watching TV totally outweigh the benefits of it.

Holden doesn’t like the movies or going to shows. It may not necessarily be television, but he despises the movies because it’s all phony, as he would put it. Nothing is real, and why would it be? It’s a dramatic play put on for the sole entertainment of others who come to watch it.

Life is already way too dramatic for us to handle, why add fictitious drama to our lives if we can help it? Limiting the amount of shows, movies, TV, and videos we watch can free us to live our own lives, rather than watch others live theirs on the big screen.

4. “Goddam money. It always ends up making you blue.”

This is one of my favorite quotes in the entire book. Why? Because it’s so true! Money, if we don’t know how to use it and manage it, can end up making us very blue indeed.

Money is one of the top 3 reasons why couples divorce. It is the subject matter of lawsuits, from the pitifully petty small court lawsuits to the large fraudulent scandals that plague corporations and organizations across the globe. Money is the driving force behind murders, violence, and crimes in our neighborhoods and cities. With enough money, it can buy us entry into some countries. It can also persuade government and local officials of your innocence in any illegal activities that may be going on. Give them enough cash often and generously and they’ll keep things quiet for the time being.

However, money in and of itself is not a bad and evil thing. It doesn’t breathe, walk, talk, and have feelings. Why else do you think they call it “cold, hard cash”?

The overt pursuit of money as it is falsely equated to happiness is what befalls us and can destroy nations. Not only that, it can ultimately destroy us.

Protect yourself from this by not placing your joy and long lasting happiness in the pursuit of acquiring more and more money. In the end, only our most loved ones will matter to us. Not how much is in our bank account, not how much we’ve earned per year, not how much your assets are valued at. All these things will pass, including us. Let us cultivate our relationships with those we care about because that is meant to last.

5. “I keep picturing all these little kids playing some game in this big field of rye and all. Thousands of little kids, and nobody’s around—nobody big, I mean—except me. And I’m standing on the edge of some crazy cliff. What I have to do, I have to catch everybody if they start to go over the cliff—I mean if they’re running and they don’t look where they’re going I have to come out from somewhere and catch them. That’s all I’d do all day. I’d just be the catcher in the rye and all. I know it’s crazy, but that’s the only thing I’d really like to be. I know it’s crazy.”

Crazy or not, you have got to be who you want to be. This should not and cannot be compromised. Life is too short to not be who you truly are.

6. “A lot of people, especially this one psychoanalyst guy they have here, keeps asking me if I’m going to apply myself when I go back to school next September. It’s such a stupid question, in my opinion. I mean how do you know what you’re going to do till you do it? The answer is, you don’t. I think I am, but how do I know? I swear it’s a stupid question.”

As much as you think you are an emotionally strong and stable person, when things start to get really rough and you completely break down, you have to wonder how far off we are in who we think we are as compared with who we actually are.

I may think I’m some bad ass martial artist just because I earned a 1st degree Black belt but will I truly be able to defend myself if I’m ever in a compromising situation late at night in Chicago? I won’t ever really know until I’m in such a situation (hopefully never …). All I can do is prepare myself as much as possible and think I’m ready. It’s better than nothing at all.

So with that, if you’ve never read The Catcher in the Rye, I highly recommend it. It’s not that long of a read and has several underlying concepts in it, as we’ve already gone through 6 of them here. It’s also pretty humorous!

Tell me, have you read it? If so, what are your thoughts?

  • missmintyfresh

    Great post.

    I especially appreciate #3. For years, I felt uncomfortable watching movies/TV and felt even more uncomfortable trying to explain why I avoided them like the plague. I despise being “sucked into” a world that isn't real…but how can one explain to her friends that being grounded in reality at all times doesn't make one the lamest person around?? Well…you've given me more food for thought (and encouragement to continue my TVless lifestyle).

    Many thanks. =) My friends on Tumblr will be seeing this post, too.

  • https://castlesintheair.org Nina | Castles in the Air

    missmintyfresh, thanks! Being yourself, TVless or not, is a great way to be, heck, the only way to be. :)

  • http://askexperience.com Brett

    I'd like to preface things by saying that I don't mean any ill-will towards you, Nina. But I've gotta pick a bone with some things that Holden – and you – say. I'll admit that #s 1,2,4,5, and 6 are pretty close to perfect, but #3? Really?

    I'll be the first to say that I don't think watching TV's good for you. 99% of shows on television are garbage. Truly. Cable news is a poor excuse for journalism. So what does that leave? Sports. I watch sports because I love the talent and athleticism that's on display, as well as the raw competition, added to the fact that I'm an athlete myself. Being a lifelong athlete/sports watcher has helped my relationships – I've been able to bond with people over the game last night or our allegiances to certain teams, for instance – and, other than losing a bit of time each night for my entertainment, I'd say watching has been a pretty good return on investment. So, am I not living life as YOU want me to live, or am I following your advice by being myself? Can't have it both ways.

    You also have to keep in mind that Holden is an extremely frustrated, isolated, misanthropic, hypocritical character; he says he derides 'phoniness', yet he lies repeatedly to that woman on the train (her name escapes me). Another one of his inconsistencies – at least, based on how you interpreted the book – is how he professes that The Great Gatsby is his favorite book. But, wait – The Great Gatsby is a work of fiction, so it must be phony, just like the movies he professes to hate. So Holden clearly doesn't follow his own clever musings…

    What's wrong with indulging in 'fake' entertainment? Sure, the empty, vapid shows like Grey's Anatomy are bad, but the best pieces of fiction – movies, TV shows, and books – connect in a universal way with humanity. The medium doesn't matter; just because the novel has been around much longer than the moving picture or the television show doesn't mean that any of the latter two cannot be just as good as the former. All that matters is how well the story resonates with its audience and how well it is crafted.

    So please, tell me why you added to the 'fictitious drama' of Holden Caulfield to your life when you had enough already. I promise I'm not trying to be a jerk or anything of that sort – honestly! I enjoy your blog! – but this giant, gaping hole in your logic has to be pointed out.

  • https://castlesintheair.org Nina | Castles in the Air

    Thanks for your comments, Brett, and I appreciate you sharing with me your thoughts on point #3, in particular.

    I will have to say that if that's the way you choose to use your time in watching entertainment, go ahead! Ultimately, whatever I write and share regarding my ideas & thoughts through my blog, one message is clear: You must be comfortable with who you are in your own skin, and not necessarily anyone else's.

    Though I do not advocate TV watching and have a very strong stance on this, those who do are not necessarily horrible people. I'll be the first to say I was a complete TV and movie junkie, watching up to 6 hours of it each night after school. Later, I realized this was a very poor use of my time and have subsequently rid myself of such activity. Because it works for me. It may not work for others, but it does for me.

    As for Holden, he is truly a nut which makes it so much more funnier! He contradicts himself, like you mentioned, all the time. But he does make several good points, 6 of which was the point of this blog post. This post was written more to cause one to think. Of course, no one has to adopt these similar viewpoints and thoughts on life. But if it causes you to pause and think about things, great! Hope this helps, Brett, and I do appreciate your honesty. Thank you for reading!

  • http://askexperience.com Brett

    Just don't get *too* caught up in your hard and fast rules. Sometimes, watching a movie may be very beneficial and worth your time.

    My vice used to be reading the news – I would spend hours and hours after school reading nothing but the news articles from papers and blogs that I had in my feed reader. Eventually, I got fed up with it so much that I cut myself off from the media altogether, and BAM! My life felt so much better. I bet you know the feeling from stopping the TV addiction!

    But, the truth is, these things aren't inherently bad – they just are when we do too much of them. So, now, I read a tiny bit of news – just whatever piques my interest from papers like The Economist and the Independent, and I move on. Maybe you'll find shows you like and watch them on occasion as well?

    At any rate, I'll never condemn anyone who makes it their mission to avoid TV. But just don't end up hating things like stories just because they're not real; all good stories have an element of truth in them, like I said. But, of course, you know that, since you've read and reread The Catcher in the Rye.

    For a really engaging read that has a lot of lessons in it (though many are hidden and ultimately up to your interpretation), pick up The Magus by John Fowles. I read it recently and was blown away. Yeah, it's pretty long, but you won't be able to put it down!

    Keep keepin' it real, Nina!

  • Kelly

    Nina,

    I really enjoy your posts! I look forward to it all the time! I completely agree with all you posted! I recently gave up tv and have never felt better!! For the most part, it is all centered around one thing, “corporate profit”! As our founding fathers told us, corporations and banks are worse than standing armies! I totally believe that.

    I have not read the book but intend to do so now.

    My goal is to live the minimalist life style you have embraced! You are a true inspiration! Keep up the good work!!

    Kelly

  • https://castlesintheair.org Nina | Castles in the Air

    I actually really love stories! They're fun, imaginative, creative, and truly a piece of work. My favorite movie is Fight Club, much of it because I resonate with Tyler Durden's life philosophies: “The things you own, end up owning you.” “You are not your job.” Etc. :)

    I'll have to look into The Magus, thanks for the book recommendation!

    Good stuff, Brett, thanks for your input into this subject matter!

  • https://castlesintheair.org Nina | Castles in the Air

    Kelly, thank you! And thanks for taking the time to read, I'm so glad my blog has inspired you to live a minimalist life. :)

  • http://twitter.com/slspace The Living Space

    It's a good read, Nina. Excellent choice. Out of curiosity, what other books (fiction) do you like to read? Doing you have a recommended reading list? I read many of the classics including the Catcher in the Rye (its a been a while).

  • Bo

    Love this. Makes me want to read the book now. It's always been on my “read someday” list, but somehow I've never actually read it.

    I do have a book that I've read at least once or twice a year, though…”Maiden Voyage.” Very cool travel story about a teenage girl…I bet you'd like it!

  • https://castlesintheair.org Nina | Castles in the Air

    Thanks for the book rec., Bo! Always welcoming recommendations. That’s one of the ways we can learn to open our minds. :)

  • https://castlesintheair.org Nina | Castles in the Air

    Thanks, Kiran! For fiction, I’ve found I enjoy John Steinbeck’s works (Travels With Charley, The Grapes of Wrath), another classic American writer. He writes mostly fictional stories but based on societal and cultural events that had taken place or was taking place during his time of writing. If an author makes me think deeper and makes me pause and reflect on what it means (whatever “it” may be, such as life, love, death, war, art, etc.), then it is probably a book worth reading.nnBut to be honest, I read a whole lot more non-fiction (business, thought-change, leadership, psychology, philosophy, self-help, biography) than fiction. Which makes it ironic that The Catcher in the Rye (a great work of fiction) is my favorite book of all time. :) nnFor a full list of what I’ve read in 2010 thus far, most of which is non-fiction, visit https://castlesintheair.org/blog/about/reading-list/.

  • https://castlesintheair.org Nina | Castles in the Air

    Thanks for the book rec., Bo! Always welcoming recommendations. That's one of the ways we can learn to open our minds. :)

  • https://castlesintheair.org Nina | Castles in the Air

    Thanks, Kiran! For fiction, I've found I enjoy John Steinbeck's works (Travels With Charley, The Grapes of Wrath), another classic American writer. He writes mostly fictional stories but based on societal and cultural events that had taken place or was taking place during his time of writing. If an author makes me think deeper and makes me pause and reflect on what it means (whatever “it” may be, such as life, love, death, war, art, etc.), then it is probably a book worth reading.

    But to be honest, I read a whole lot more non-fiction (business, thought-change, leadership, psychology, philosophy, self-help, biography) than fiction. Which makes it ironic that The Catcher in the Rye (a great work of fiction) is my favorite book of all time. :)

    For a full list of what I've read in 2010 thus far, most of which is non-fiction, visit https://castlesintheair.org/blog/about/reading-l....

blog comments powered by Disqus